Portfolio Protection and Award Finality - WAMR - 2021 Vol. 15, No. 2
Ryan D. McKeever is a J.D. Candidate, 2026, University of Florida Levin College of Law.
Originally from World Arbitration and Mediation Review (WAMR)
PREVIEW
This article analyzes the distinct regulatory framework governing Registered Investment Advisers (RIAs) and broker-dealers by highlighting the crucial differences in their history, governing bodies, and duties to investors. From here, the respective arbitration forums in which investors must bring their claims are discussed, focusing on the American Arbitration Association’s (AAA) procedures for RIAs and the mechanism created by the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) for broker-dealers. This exploration highlights the key advantage for investors working with RIAs, which is that the AAA offers optional appellate arbitration procedures. This is important as FINRA not only lacks optional appellate arbitration procedures but expressly denies them. This absence is particularly concerning given the less stringent suitability and “best interest” standard broker-dealers must follow, which can lead to potentially worse behavior when compared to the stronger fiduciary duty of RIAs. This paper concludes by encouraging FINRA to implement an optional appellate procedure to enhance fairness and investor protection within its arbitration forum, as well as the securities industry at large.
I. INTRODUCTION
A secure financial future is an integral part of the American dream and often involves investors depending on financial professionals. This path nonetheless is complicated by a complex regulatory structure. The array of rules and regulators within the financial industry challenges both investors and professionals to fully understand their obligations and rights. Adding to this complexity is the variety of financial products available in the market today. These range from traditional instruments such as stocks and bonds to alternative investments such as cryptocurrencies and real estate.
More specifically, the choice of who to entrust their money with, whether a registered investment adviser (“RIA”) or broker-dealer can confuse investors, potentially leading to devastating consequences from misunderstandings or misconduct. For example, a recent news report highlighted how quickly a financial advisor was able to drain retirees’ investment accounts by showcasing one couple who lost over $350,000. The report detailed how funds, allegedly placed into speculative or fraudulent investments, were represented as safe for retirement, only to then vanish.
This article outlines the regulatory framework governing RIAs and broker-dealers, including their laws, regulators, compensation, and standards of care, as well as provides an overview of how these evolved. The article will then delve into the distinct arbitration forums where investors must resolve their claims when disputes arise with these professionals. Specifically, this focuses on the rules governing arbitration awards and their finality. Ultimately, this analysis will highlight the difference between the American Arbitration Association (AAA), which offers optional appellate arbitration, and the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) which does not. This is particularly concerning given the less strict suitability standard broker-dealers follow compared to the more comprehensive fiduciary duty of RIAs. The absence of optional appellate procedures within FINRA means that if an arbitration panel makes a significant error, investors may have very limited recourse to challenge the decision. Finally, this paper will suggest that FINRA should implement an optional appellate arbitration process of its own, to enhance fairness within the industry, align with the spirit of the Federal Arbitration Act (“FAA”), and provide additional safeguards for investors.
